Performing Node Maintenance in a Mesos Cluster

Operators regularly need to perform maintenance tasks on machines that comprise a Mesos cluster. Most Mesos upgrades can be done without affecting running tasks, but there are situations where maintenance may affect running tasks. For example:

  • Hardware repair
  • Kernel upgrades
  • Agent upgrades (e.g., adjusting agent attributes or resources)

Before performing maintenance on an agent node in a Mesos cluster, it is typically desirable to gracefully migrate tasks away from the node beforehand in order to minimize service disruption when the machine is taken down. Mesos provides several ways to accomplish this migration:

  • Automatic agent draining, which does not explicitly require cooperation from schedulers
  • Manual node draining, which allows operators to exercise precise control over the task draining process
  • Maintenance primitives, which permit complex coordination but do require that schedulers react to the maintenance-related messages that they receive

Automatic Node Draining

Node draining was added to provide a simple method for operators to drain tasks from nodes on which they plan to perform maintenance, without requiring that schedulers implement support for any maintenance-specific messages.

Initiating draining will cause all tasks on the target agent node to receive a kill event immediately, assuming the agent is currently reachable. If the agent is unreachable, initiation of the kill event will be delayed until the agent is reachable by the master again. When the tasks receive a kill event, a SIGTERM signal will be sent to the task to begin the killing process. Depending on the particular task's behavior, this signal may be sufficient to terminate it. Some tasks may use this signal to begin the process of graceful termination, which may take some time. After some delay, a SIGKILL signal will be sent to the task, which forcefully terminates the task if it is still running. The delay between the SIGTERM and SIGKILL signals is determined by the length of the task's kill grace period. If no grace period is set for the task, a default value of several seconds will be used.

Initiating Draining on a Node

To begin draining an agent, issue the operator API DRAIN_AGENT call to the master:

$ curl -X POST -d '{"type": "DRAIN_AGENT", "drain_agent": {"agent_id": {"value": "<mesos-agent-id>"}}}' masterhost:5050/api/v1

This will immediately begin the process of killing all tasks on the agent. Once draining has begun, it cannot be cancelled. To monitor the progress of the draining process, you can inspect the state of the agent via the master operator API GET_STATE or GET_AGENTS calls:

$ curl -X POST -d '{"type": "GET_AGENTS"}' masterhost:5050/api/v1

Locate the relevant agent and inspect its drain_info.state field. While draining, the state will be DRAINING. When all tasks on the agent have terminated, all their terminal status updates have been acknowledged by the schedulers, and all offer operations on the agent have finished, draining is complete and the agent's drain state will transition to DRAINED. At this point, the node may be taken down for maintenance.

Options for Automatic Node Draining

You may set an upper bound on the kill grace period of draining tasks by specifying the max_grace_period option when draining:

$ curl -X POST -d '{"type": "DRAIN_AGENT", "drain_agent": {"agent_id": {"value": "<mesos-agent-id>"}, "max_grace_period": "10mins"}}' masterhost:5050/api/v1

In cases where you know that the node being drained will not return after draining is complete, and you would like it to be automatically permanently removed from the cluster, you may specify the mark_gone option:

$ curl -X POST -d '{"type": "DRAIN_AGENT", "drain_agent": {"agent_id": {"value": "<mesos-agent-id>"}, "mark_gone": true}}' masterhost:5050/api/v1

This can be useful, for example, in the case of autoscaled cloud instances, where an instance is being scaled down and will never return. This is equivalent to issuing the MARK_AGENT_GONE call on the agent immediately after it finishes draining. WARNING: draining with the mark_gone option is irreversible, and results in the loss of all local persistent data on the agent node. Use this option with caution!

Reactivating a Node After Maintenance

Once maintenance on an agent is complete, it must be reactivated so that it can reregister with the master and rejoin the cluster. You may use the master operator API REACTIVATE_AGENT call to accomplish this:

$ curl -X POST -d '{"type": "REACTIVATE_AGENT", "reactivate_agent": {"agent_id": {"value": "<mesos-agent-id>"}}}' masterhost:5050/api/v1

Manual Node Draining

If you require greater control over the draining process, you may be able to drain the agent manually using both the Mesos operator API as well as APIs exposed by the schedulers running tasks on the agent.

Deactivating an Agent

The first step in the manual draining process is agent deactivation, which prevents new tasks from launching on the target agent:

$ curl -X POST -d '{"type": "DEACTIVATE_AGENT", "deactivate_agent": {"agent_id": {"value": "<mesos-agent-id>"}}}' masterhost:5050/api/v1

If you receive a 200 OK response, then the agent has been deactivated. You can confirm the deactivation state of any agent by inspecting its deactivated field in the response of the master operator API GET_STATE or GET_AGENTS calls. Once the agent is deactivated, you can use the APIs exposed by the schedulers responsible for the tasks running on the agent to kill those tasks manually. To verify that all tasks on the agent have terminated and their terminal status updates have been acknowledged by the schedulers, ensure that the pending_tasks, queued_tasks, and launched_tasks fields in the response to the GET_TASKS agent operator API call are empty:

$ curl -X POST -d '{"type": "GET_TASKS"}' agenthost:5051/api/v1

If you are making use of volumes backed by network storage on the target agent, it's possible that there may be a long-running offer operation on the agent which has not yet finished. To check if this is the case, issue the agent operator API GET_OPERATIONS call to the agent:

$ curl -X POST -d '{"type": "GET_OPERATIONS"}' agenthost:5051/api/v1

If any operations have a latest_status with a state of OPERATION_PENDING, you should wait for them to finish before taking down the node. Unfortunately, it is not possible to cancel or forcefully terminate such storage operations. If such an operation becomes stuck in the pending state, you should inspect the relevant storage backend for any issues.

Once all tasks on the agent have terminated and all offer operations are finished, the node may be taken down for maintenance. Once maintenance is complete, the procedure for reactivating the node is the same as that detailed in the section on automatic node draining.

Maintenance Primitives

Frameworks require visibility into any actions that disrupt cluster operation in order to meet Service Level Agreements or to ensure uninterrupted services for their end users. Therefore, to reconcile the requirements of frameworks and operators, frameworks must be aware of planned maintenance events and operators must be aware of frameworks' ability to adapt to maintenance. Maintenance primitives add a layer to facilitate communication between the frameworks and operator.

Terminology

For the purpose of this section, an "Operator" is a person, tool, or script that manages a Mesos cluster.

Maintenance primitives add several new concepts to Mesos. Those concepts are:

  • Maintenance: An operation that makes resources on a machine unavailable, either temporarily or permanently.
  • Maintenance window: A set of machines and an associated time interval during which some maintenance is planned on those machines.
  • Maintenance schedule: A list of maintenance windows. A single machine may only appear in a schedule once.
  • Unavailability: An operator-specified interval, defined by a start time and duration, during which an associated machine may become unavailable. In general, no assumptions should be made about the availability of the machine (or resources) after the unavailability.
  • Drain: An interval between the scheduling of maintenance and when the machine(s) become unavailable. Offers sent with resources from draining machines will contain unavailability information. Frameworks running on draining machines will receive inverse offers (see next). Frameworks utilizing resources on affected machines are expected either to take preemptive steps to prepare for the unavailability; or to communicate the framework's inability to conform to the maintenance schedule.
  • Inverse offer: A communication mechanism for the master to ask for resources back from a framework. This notifies frameworks about any unavailability and gives frameworks a mechanism to respond about their ability to comply. Inverse offers are similar to offers in that they can be accepted, declined, re-offered, and rescinded.

Note: Unavailability and inverse offers are not specific to maintenance. The same concepts can be used for non-maintenance goals, such as reallocating resources or resource preemption.

How does it work?

Maintenance primitives were introduced in Mesos 0.25.0. Several machine maintenance modes were also introduced. Those modes are illustrated below.

Maintenance mode transitions

All mode transitions must be initiated by the operator. Mesos will not change the mode of any machine, regardless of the estimate provided in the maintenance schedule.

Scheduling maintenance

A machine is transitioned from Up mode to Draining mode as soon as it is scheduled for maintenance. To transition a machine into Draining mode, an operator constructs a maintenance schedule as a JSON document and posts it to the /maintenance/schedule HTTP endpoint on the Mesos master. Each Mesos cluster has a single maintenance schedule; posting a new schedule replaces the previous schedule, if any.

See the definition of a maintenance::Schedule and of Unavailability.

In a production environment, the schedule should be constructed to ensure that enough agents are operational at any given point in time to ensure uninterrupted service by the frameworks.

For example, in a cluster of three machines, the operator might schedule two machines for one hour of maintenance, followed by another hour for the last machine. The timestamps for unavailability are expressed in nanoseconds since the Unix epoch (note that making reliable use of maintenance primitives requires that the system clocks of all machines in the cluster are roughly synchronized).

The schedule might look like:

{
  "windows" : [
    {
      "machine_ids" : [
        { "hostname" : "machine1", "ip" : "10.0.0.1" },
        { "hostname" : "machine2", "ip" : "10.0.0.2" }
      ],
      "unavailability" : {
        "start" : { "nanoseconds" : 1443830400000000000 },
        "duration" : { "nanoseconds" : 3600000000000 }
      }
    }, {
      "machine_ids" : [
        { "hostname" : "machine3", "ip" : "10.0.0.3" }
      ],
      "unavailability" : {
        "start" : { "nanoseconds" : 1443834000000000000 },
        "duration" : { "nanoseconds" : 3600000000000 }
      }
    }
  ]
}

The operator can then post the schedule to the master's /maintenance/schedule endpoint:

curl http://localhost:5050/maintenance/schedule \
  -H "Content-type: application/json" \
  -X POST \
  -d @schedule.json

The machines in a maintenance schedule do not need to be registered with the Mesos master at the time when the schedule is set. The operator may add a machine to the maintenance schedule prior to launching an agent on the machine. For example, this can be useful to prevent a faulty machine from launching an agent on boot.

Note: Each machine in the maintenance schedule should have as complete information as possible. In order for Mesos to recognize an agent as coming from a particular machine, both the hostname and ip fields must match. Any omitted data defaults to the empty string "". If there are multiple hostnames or IPs for a machine, the machine's fields need to match what the agent announces to the master. If there is any ambiguity in a machine's configuration, the operator should use the --hostname and --ip options when starting agents.

The master checks that a maintenance schedule has the following properties:

  • Each maintenance window in the schedule must have at least one machine and a specified unavailability interval.
  • Each machine must only appear in the schedule once.
  • Each machine must have at least a hostname or IP included. The hostname is not case-sensitive.
  • All machines that are in Down mode must be present in the schedule. This is required because this endpoint does not handle the transition from Down mode to Up mode.

If any of these properties are not met, the maintenance schedule is rejected with a corresponding error message and the master's state is not changed.

To update the maintenance schedule, the operator should first read the current schedule, make any necessary changes, and then post the modified schedule. The current maintenance schedule can be obtained by sending a GET request to the master's /maintenance/schedule endpoint.

To cancel the maintenance schedule, the operator should post an empty schedule.

Draining mode

As soon as a schedule is posted to the Mesos master, the following things occur:

  • The schedule is stored in the replicated log. This means the schedule is persisted in case of master failover.
  • All machines in the schedule are immediately transitioned into Draining mode. The mode of each machine is also persisted in the replicated log.
  • All frameworks using resources on affected agents are immediately notified. Existing offers from the affected agents are rescinded and re-sent with additional unavailability data. All frameworks using resources from the affected agents are given inverse offers.
  • New offers from the affected agents will also include the additional unavailability data.

Frameworks should use this additional information to schedule tasks in a maintenance-aware fashion. Exactly how to do this depends on the design requirements of each scheduler, but tasks should typically be scheduled in a way that maximizes utilization but that also attempts to vacate machines before that machine's advertised unavailability period occurs. A scheduler might choose to place long-running tasks on machines with no unavailability, or failing that, on machines whose unavailability is the furthest away.

How a framework responds to an inverse offer indicates its ability to conform to the maintenance schedule. Accepting an inverse offer communicates that the framework is okay with the current maintenance schedule, given the current state of the framework's resources. The master and operator should interpret acceptance as a best-effort promise by the framework to free all the resources contained in the inverse offer before the start of the unavailability interval. Declining an inverse offer is an advisory notice to the operator that the framework is unable or unlikely to meet to the maintenance schedule.

For example:

  • A data store may choose to start a new replica if one of its agents is scheduled for maintenance. The data store should accept an inverse offer if it can reasonably copy the data on the machine to a new host before the unavailability interval described in the inverse offer begins. Otherwise, the data store should decline the offer.
  • A stateful task on an agent with an impending unavailability may be migrated to another available agent. If the framework has sufficient resources to do so, it would accept any inverse offers. Otherwise, it would decline them.

A framework can use a filter to control when it wants to be contacted again with an inverse offer. This is useful since future circumstances may change the viability of the maintenance schedule. The filter for inverse offers is identical to the existing mechanism for re-offering offers to frameworks.

Note: Accepting or declining an inverse offer does not result in immediate changes in the maintenance schedule or in the way Mesos acts. Inverse offers only represent extra information that frameworks may find useful. In the same manner, rejecting or accepting an inverse offer is a hint for an operator. The operator may or may not choose to take that hint into account.

Starting maintenance

The operator starts maintenance by posting a list of machines to the /machine/down HTTP endpoint. The list of machines is specified in JSON format; each element of the list is a MachineID.

For example, to start maintenance on two machines:

[
  { "hostname" : "machine1", "ip" : "10.0.0.1" },
  { "hostname" : "machine2", "ip" : "10.0.0.2" }
]

curl http://localhost:5050/machine/down \
  -H "Content-type: application/json" \
  -X POST \
  -d @machines.json

The master checks that a list of machines has the following properties:

  • The list of machines must not be empty.
  • Each machine must only appear once.
  • Each machine must have at least a hostname or IP included. The hostname is not case-sensitive.
  • If a machine's IP is included, it must be correctly formed.
  • All listed machines must be present in the schedule.

If any of these properties are not met, the operation is rejected with a corresponding error message and the master's state is not changed.

The operator can start maintenance on any machine that is scheduled for maintenance. Machines that are not scheduled for maintenance cannot be directly transitioned from Up mode into Down mode. However, the operator may schedule a machine for maintenance with a timestamp equal to the current time or in the past, and then immediately start maintenance on that machine.

This endpoint can be used to start maintenance on machines that are not currently registered with the Mesos master. This can be useful if a machine has failed and the operator intends to remove it from the cluster; starting maintenance on the machine prevents the machine from being accidentally rebooted and rejoining the Mesos cluster.

The operator must explicitly transition a machine from Draining to Down mode. That is, Mesos will keep a machine in Draining mode even if the unavailability window arrives or passes. This means that the operation of the machine is not disrupted in any way and offers (with unavailability information) are still sent for this machine.

When maintenance is triggered by the operator, all agents on the machine are told to shutdown. These agents are removed from the master, which means that a TASK_LOST status update will be sent for every task running on each of those agents. The scheduler driver's slaveLost callback will also be invoked for each of the removed agents. Any agents on machines in maintenance are also prevented from reregistering with the master in the future (until maintenance is completed and the machine is brought back up).

Completing maintenance

When maintenance is complete or if maintenance needs to be cancelled, the operator can stop maintenance. The process is very similar to starting maintenance (same validation criteria as the previous section). The operator posts a list of machines to the master's /machine/up endpoint:

[
  { "hostname" : "machine1", "ip" : "10.0.0.1" },
  { "hostname" : "machine2", "ip" : "10.0.0.2" }
]

curl http://localhost:5050/machine/up \
  -H "Content-type: application/json" \
  -X POST \
  -d @machines.json

Note: The duration of the maintenance window, as indicated by the "unavailability" field in the maintenance schedule, is a best-effort guess made by the operator. Stopping maintenance before the end of the unavailability interval is allowed, as is stopping maintenance after the end of the unavailability interval. Machines are never automatically transitioned out of maintenance.

Frameworks are informed about the completion or cancellation of maintenance when offers from that machine start being sent. There is no explicit mechanism for notifying frameworks when maintenance has finished. After maintenance has finished, new offers are no longer tagged with unavailability and inverse offers are no longer sent. Also, agents running on the machine will be allowed to register with the Mesos master.

Viewing maintenance status

The current maintenance status (Up, Draining, or Down) of each machine in the cluster can be viewed by accessing the master's /maintenance/status HTTP endpoint. For each machine that is Draining, this endpoint also includes the frameworks' responses to inverse offers for resources on that machine. For more information, see the format of the ClusterStatus message.

NOTE: The format of the data returned by this endpoint may change in a future release of Mesos.